Re: 4L60E for 600+HP GMHTP May 09' P.80
This thread didn't bring up anything that I haven't heard before... but let me ask this has anyone read the article yet? I'm guessing no because I had the page number wrong. The article starts on page. 74.
Take a look at it if you get a chance and see if you come up to the same conclusion I have.
First, let me say that I was in the same school of thought that you guys are ...the 700R4/4L60E is junk. I have seen them grenade in bolt on F-bodies that hook and I have read more than a few threads about the SYTY guys killing them with trucks in stock form, much less modified.
I have also dealt with the headaches of a blown tranny in a heavy AWD vehicle... My dad has an Escalade ESV (5700+ LBS) with a magnacharger, LT's and some other bolt ons. For being a land-barge it's no slouch. I ran a 99' Cobra dead even to 70 from a roll.
The tranny was slipping between 3 and 4 on the highway (I would like to note that the tranny was slipping before I ran the cobra) so I pulled it out and had it rebuilt. Then the pump blew within 1,000 miles. New pump was $500 and the performance torque converter he bought was trashed. Tranny was rebuilt again and I put it in. Luckily I noticed that the flexplate was warped when I checked it, which was likely the cause of the blown pump. New flexplate and I put it back together. Still didn't shift right. The whole time I was telling my old man that he needed to upgrade the tranny... It's only a 4L65E! I kept telling him that HP+AWD+Weight= tranny death. He finally took it to a tranny shop. Turns out our GM tech we had rebuild the tranny after hours did a shitty job. It needed a new main bearing and new servos. Will it hold up now? I have my doubts. I do know that it was a ginormous pain in the butt to take the t-case and all the other crap out just to get to the tranny. And I seriously had no fun doing it 3 times in a row.
Now for my thoughts on the GMHTP article. When I first started reading it I was thinking, "How the heck are they going to beef up such a weak tranny?" The article confirmed that the 4L60E is junk in stock form. But that taking the 65E planetary and a billet steel output shaft along with a host of other factory and aftermarket upgrades to the 60E one can make a descent tranny. I was thinking that this route might not be a bad way to go. While the 80E swap is a good idea, it's not a simple drop in. Yeah the cores are cheap, but you need the controller, crossmember, propshaft, etc... it all adds up. It's something else to fiddle with and adds something that can go wrong.
Maybe I'm jaded because my last 'swap' snowballed. I wanted a LT1 in my GMC sonoma. I now have a built LT4 with the alternator being the only untouched component on it, a new custom driveshaft, custom radiator, narrowed back half, ford 9", 4-linked, fuel celled truck that is more suited for the track than getting groceries. Do I enjoy it? Now that I finally got the time to put the finishing touches on it and put it back on the road, yes. Did I put more money into it than I ever thought I would? Yes.
I put forged pistons and H-beams into my TY for reliability. Yeah, I threw on L35 heads and got a better turbo. Do I plan on cranking up the boost? No. Am I going to drive it every day? No. Fortunately I have an 94' V-6 camaro that can share the duties.
The thought of keeping things simple with a built 700R4 is appealing. Will I go that route? I don't know. The pricetag seemed a little bit high for the stage II build. I don't want to know what the stage IV costs. I would have to consider that compared to an 80E swap. But as of right now, I don't even have the truck back together yet. We'll have to see how long the GM replacement TY 700R4 with 35,000 miles lasts. It also depends on whether or not the person doing a 700R4 build would back it for the torque/weight of the TY. I am also interested in hearing if any guys out there have built 700R4's to this degree and if/when they let go.
I guess this long post needs a summary. I think that a fully built 700R4 may work may work in my situation. I want to keep it simple. My build isn't crazy and when I really want to go fast I have something else to go crazy in. In theory this should keep the urge to boost launch at bay.
Knowing all this, what do you guys think now?